網路城邦
上一篇 回創作列表 下一篇  字體:
紐約奇聞:開車撞死人無罪,因為不是故意的
2009/02/14 03:20:48瀏覽2853|回應7|推薦14

http://www.google.com/hostednews/ap/article/ALeqM5hD4DvEyWd-TaZH9bCceVpzcE_D5QD96AARPG0

真的很難相信世界上會有這種事,今天的報紙上登出來,有一個到美國來打工的厄瓜多爾人,在剛滿二十六歲生日的第二天,走在紐約市街頭,先被一輛SUV(休旅車)撞到,隨之一輛Van開過,他被掛在車子底下,一路被拖行了二十英哩(相當於三十二公里),也就是一小時之後,才被車主發現。早已斷氣身亡,上衣掉在路上,衣服被磨破,全身傷痕累累。

那個拖行的車主說,他什麼也不知道,中途他覺得車子有點怪,曾下車查看,但是沒有注意到車子底下。一直到停下來以後,才有路人告訴他車子底下有人。

警方找到了這二個開車的人,警方說,他們不準備控告這兩個撞死人的駕駛,因為這整件事是個純粹意外,因為這兩個駕駛不是故意撞死人的。

因為不是故意撞死人的,所以不必上法庭,是不是故意的,有沒有罪,由警察可以直接決定。這是我今年以來,聽到過最離譜的事。到底,這是個人治的國家,還是法治的國家?

非故意而致人於死,在台灣法律叫做過失殺人,或是過失致死,看情節輕重,是有減刑或是免刑的可能,但是說不必經過司法審判,就直接免責,這我還是第一次聽說,但卻白紙黑字的寫在報紙上。

當然,受害者家屬還是可以自行提告的,這變成了告訴乃論,撞死人竟然是告訴乃論的事,不由得受氣包拍案驚奇。萬一受害者沒有家屬,或是家屬不懂如何提告怎麼辦?

另外,撞死了人,就算完全沒有刑責好了,難道不必負一點金錢上的賠償責任?該男子剛滿二十六歲,跑到美國來打工賺錢,每個月固定寄錢回去給厄瓜多爾的家人,是一家的經濟支柱,如今他死了,他的家人總該得到一點賠償吧!

警察竟然完全不提告,令人難以置信。我不相信如果今天撞死的是個政客,明星,還是市長的什麼人,還是警察局長的人麼人,這個事會如此罷休。我沒有辦法不聯想,這是因為厄瓜多爾人的命不值錢。

Photo 1 of 4

In this image taken from video, police investigate the body of a middle-aged man under a van in the Coney Island neighborhood of Brooklyn, N.Y., Wednesday, Feb. 11, 2009. The man was hit by an SUV in Queens, then swept under the van and dragged nearly 17 miles on New York City highways before the driver discovered the body in Brooklyn. (AP Photo/APTN, GSN News)

©2009 Google - Map data ©2009 Tele Atlas - Terms of Use

Victim dragged under van identified as Ecuadorean

NEW YORK (AP) — The man who was hit by a car, trapped under a van and dragged for nearly 20 miles through the city was a hardworking immigrant who religiously sent money home to his wife and daughter in Ecuador, relatives said Thursday.

Guido Salvador Carabajo-Jara turned 26 the day before he was killed in Wednesday's gruesome accident. He was crossing a busy street near his home in Queens when he was hit by an SUV, then impaled by a steel plate under a second vehicle, a van. His body wasn't discovered until the van driver arrived in Brooklyn about an hour later.

His sister, Rosa Carabajo, and his cousin Felix Jara returned to their Queens neighborhood Thursday from the hospital morgue, weeping and distressed.

"He was an excellent person, very easygoing, very happy," Jara said in Spanish. "I was in shock. We don't know how this could have happened. I didn't believe it until I saw his saw his face."

Police said the death was accidental and that they have no plans to charge the two drivers, who both have clean driving records. The miles of dragging wore off the hair on the back of Carabajo-Jara's head and his clothing and skin on his legs and buttocks.

An autopsy found that Carabajo-Jara died from multiple blunt-impact injuries, medical examiner spokeswoman Ellen Borakove said Thursday. It hadn't been determined whether he died before the van started dragging him.

Details emerged Thursday from police and relatives about the victim, who shared an apartment with his cousin and sister. Carabajo-Jara's wife and mother live in Ecuador.

Another relative, Ignacio Quintero, said Carabajo-Jara had a 4-year-old daughter in Ecuador and faithfully sent money back to his family there to care for the girl. He described Carabajo-Jara as a hard worker whose mission was to provide for his child and save enough money to build a home in Ecuador.

"The family is destroyed," Quintero said in Spanish. "They are in a lot of pain."

Carabajo-Jara was supposed to meet Felix Jara at 8 a.m. Wednesday to go to work laying tile in Brooklyn. When he didn't show, his family spent the day looking for him.

It wasn't until about 11 p.m. Wednesday that police notified them that he had been killed. No identification had been found with Carabajo-Jara — only a business card, Western Union receipt and broken iPhone.

He was hit Wednesday morning in the Corona section of Queens, while apparently crossing against the light. The driver, Gustavo Acosta, called police, who arrived to find the victim gone.

About two vehicles behind, though, Manual Lituma Sanchez ran over Carabajo-Jara with his van, and Carabajo-Jara became hooked to the underside of the van. Unaware of anything wrong, Lituma Sanchez drove to Brooklyn, ending up in Brighton Beach, where he worked as a delivery man, police said.

At one point, he even suspected something was wrong, pulled over and checked under the hood. But he did not look under the car.

"I didn't feel anything, and I didn't hear anything," Lituma Sanchez told reporters Wednesday. "I didn't know what happened."

The van traveled for nearly an hour before a pedestrian alerted the driver to something dragging under the van. It was only then that Lituma Sanchez saw the body and called authorities.

Police retraced the van's route and recovered a blue jacket believed to have belonged to the victim. Grisly surveillance video showed the body disappearing, swept underneath the van moments after being hit by the SUV. A white car is shown swerving in between.

"Everyone is crying, especially in my country," Jara said. "Everyone is going crazy."

It was the third death of an Ecuadorean immigrant to shock New Yorkers in a little more than three months.

Jose Oswaldo Sucuzhanay, a 31-year-old real estate agent, was walking arm in arm with his brother in Brooklyn in December when he was beaten to death in an apparent hate crime by assailants who shouted anti-Hispanic and anti-gay slurs.

That killing followed the death on Long Island of Marcelo Lucero, 37, an Ecuadorean immigrant who was fatally stabbed Nov. 8. Prosecutors allege that seven teenagers charged in Lucero's assault had set out to attack a Hispanic person.

( 時事評論政治 )
回應 推薦文章 列印 加入我的文摘
上一篇 回創作列表 下一篇

引用
引用網址:https://classic-blog.udn.com/article/trackback.jsp?uid=ubhuang&aid=2646763

 回應文章

yensu
等級:6
留言加入好友
在台灣也是一樣
2009/02/19 02:30
在台灣也是一樣,沒有身份又黑牌的外籍勞工陳屍在荒郊野外,警察通知記者來拍拍照,再通知葬儀社處理,沒有人去追究後來的情況
時季常(ubhuang) 於 2009-02-20 01:13 回覆:

唉,人命確有貴賤之別。



等級:
留言加入好友
第二個駕駛說是意外還可以, 第一個撞了人怎麼能沒事?
2009/02/15 14:15
不補助沒收入大概是鼓勵人好歹有份工作, 不要不事生產等救濟.

九軌
等級:6
留言加入好友
crossing against the light
2009/02/15 04:20

請讀第十二段﹕

He was hit Wednesday morning in the Corona section of Queens, while apparently crossing against the light.
其他的媒體也有同樣的敘述。

 

我看過一集魯豫有約﹐一個年輕的電腦工程師﹐半夜在北京外環上開車﹐突然撞上了一個跨越公路的精神病患﹐高速公路上的行速加上剛剛過一個彎道﹐他還沒看到人﹐就已經撞上了﹐根本來不及反應﹐根據前一天剛剛頒佈的法律﹐他有刑事責任和民事責任﹐他的人生全毀了﹐何止是欲哭無淚。

法治國家有法治國家的做法﹐我只是就事論事﹐再替您加一個話題作結吧﹐美國的失業率只統計過去半年失業的人﹐失業超過半年不算失業人口﹗

時季常(ubhuang) 於 2009-02-15 15:10 回覆:

我想強調的是,不管那二個駕駛有沒有罪,至少要到法院來決定,不能由警察說了算。

紐約警方直接就把案子結了,算了,這是完全不尊重人命的態度。

我的直覺是,那個厄瓜多爾人,少說也有一百多磅吧!車底下掛個一百多磅的人,在紐約市區裡那種開開停停的路況下,開了二十幾英哩的路,竟然說會沒有發現,我覺得是鬼話。

另外,所謂闖紅燈一事,不知是根據什麼決定的,誰看到了?這個事也不該由沒有在場的記者或警察片面之言來決定吧。

路人闖紅燈被撞,在非故意的情形下,撞到人的駕駛或許可以減刑或無罪,但這個至少要交到法院來決定,警察沒有司法權力,就算有司法權力,也應要有審理過程,不應該對人命如此輕率。


九軌
等級:6
留言加入好友
要NYPD開闖紅燈的罰單嗎﹖
2009/02/15 02:56

嘿嘿﹐我沒有踢館的習慣﹐也沒有意圖要來挑戰您的權威﹐雖然很難相信世界上會有這種事﹐但是就發生了﹐就被遠在天涯海角的我們拿來談論了。

 

不是我阿Q﹐我也不是什麼善良的人﹐只是知道要知法守法﹐關於這個案子﹐真理勝于雄辯﹐您如果有知性的好奇﹐或是尊重您居住地的法律﹐不妨就在路邊隨便抽樣問問各個階層的人的意見﹐給您些參考﹐免得讓人誤以為您的說法是別有用心。

 

說回來﹐您要NYPD做什麼呢﹖莫非還要追究他們該開張闖紅燈的罰單給Guido Salvador Carabajo-Jara

時季常(ubhuang) 於 2009-02-15 03:40 回覆:

你踢不了我的館。真理不是在於法律怎麼寫,真理在於人命關天!

你提到尊重居住地的法律,那裡有什麼法律,按這個例子,根本是警察說了算!完全的人治。

不知道你為什麼一直在提闖紅燈的事?這裡頭有提到那個人闖紅燈嗎?

車底掛了一個人,在紐約市那種地方,能夠開車開了三十公里(一個小時),都不知道,這種鬼話竟會有人相信。

你在台灣有沒有聽過這種事?大巴士把人撞成了重傷,趕快再加撞一下,故意把人撞死,以免麻煩。(喪葬費只要付一次,醫療費卻是沒完沒了)。

焉知這個駕駛不是知道自己闖禍了,乾脆假裝不知道?

疑點重重,警方竟然就此結案,而司法也就不了了之。如果這個被撞死的人有點地位,絕對不會如此。

你知道紐約州有個很奇特的貧窮補助規定嗎?他們補助低收入戶,不補助沒收入戶。


九軌
等級:6
留言加入好友
My condolences to the victim's family
2009/02/14 16:10

Below is the highest rating of the comment under the Mail Online World News:

Oh my god, what a terribly tragic and horrific chain of events. I also sincerely hope that the poor victim was dead when he ended up under the van.

Another victim of this accident is the van driver - I just can't imagine the horror and guilt that's going to haunt him for a long long time although it's not his fault.

My condolences to the victim's family.

還有﹐這件事跟移民與否﹐沒有關係﹐不要把事情複雜化﹐要替受害人禱告﹐受害人除了死者﹐還有駕駛們和他們的親友們。

時季常(ubhuang) 於 2009-02-14 22:29 回覆:

你太阿Q了,怎麼可能和移民無關?如果死者不是厄多瓜爾人,這個事會這麼的輕易了事?

撞死人,連上法院都不需要,我不知道你的法治觀念在那裡!


九軌
等級:6
留言加入好友
這是一樁可以避免的悲劇﹐如果沒有闖紅燈
2009/02/14 16:04

多年以前﹐大陸剛剛開放﹐一位上海同濟的高才生到美國留學﹐是我的同學﹐一天﹐他駕的車的在高速公路上拋錨﹐他停車開門出來﹐被後面跟上高速行駛中的車撞死了。即使法律上無罪﹐那位駕駛當然還是很難過﹐也願意給予他的家人補償﹐可是﹐什麼能補償一個優秀的年輕人﹖ 我們也不必在此述說家人朋友的震撼和傷痛﹐誰來補償這個駕駛一生的歉疚﹖只能說﹐到美國除了教室裡面的學習﹐生活上有更多的教材。

我不會把這篇的標題寫成“奇聞”﹐而會寫“悲劇”﹐我常常在高速公路上開車﹐深知如果我在那一刻正好在同濟高才生後面﹐我就是那個一輩子揹負罪惡感的駕駛。我也曾經在紐約街頭看過各種驚險的畫面﹐我自然是沒膽在紐約開車﹐不過如果我要坐在van的駕駛座上隨時眼觀八方行過紐約街頭﹐我的車緊緊的跟著前車﹐我肯定就是那個Manual Lituma Sanchez

交通號誌和交通規則是要遵守的﹐要不然地上的那條線是生死線﹐紅綠燈是判死活的生死燈號。如果死者沒有闖紅燈﹐這是一樁可以避免的悲劇。

時季常(ubhuang) 於 2009-02-14 22:33 回覆:

我相信你是個善良的人,但這個事怎麼被你講得好像那個被撞死的人是活該討楣一樣?

這篇文章的目的是在講紐約警方的處理態度,而不是在講這個悲劇。


【無★言】時代悲劇 (二)
等級:8
留言加入好友
結局可能不同
2009/02/14 09:23
若是移民撞死老美,結局肯定不同.
時季常(ubhuang) 於 2009-02-14 22:39 回覆:

美國警察對少數民族的暴虐史,是斑斑血淚,而且還是進行式,時不時都有發生。

如果撞死的是美國遊民,大概也不會有什麼事。