我們日常生活的費用總是要支出。

將原本需用現金支出的改成用消費劵支付，現金存下來。

也許高官的智商真是深不可測，我們凡人參不透吧。

左思右想，發消費劵除了增加成本外，跟發"現金"有何不同。

這個政府可能認為每個人每年的生活支出花不到3600元吧。哈哈

發消費券當然是為了要刺激消費呀

想現成現金不消費就是存起來

不能增加GDP國內生產毛額吧

那消費券的意義就沒了

而且GDP是算當年的最終消費產出

股票或貨幣投資應該對GDP都沒有幫助喔

Gold prices go up because everybody is thinking too simple like you and this kind of speculative increase in gold price will not be able to protect your "real" asset value unless you liquidate it at the appropriate time. (Just the same when you invest in stock to avoid devaluation of your dollar.)

For a economic crisis of such magnitude, I personally think that there is nothing to be fear of because all the governments cannot just sit there doing nothing.  Things should be normalized if not countered by 2nd half of 2009, latest beginning of 2010. 

The only thing bad for Taiwan is that you guys have election every two years that topples your world upside down then downside up.  Everybody then go crazy and forget real business.  Like a sick man, just when he gets a bit better, you punch him down again.  How can he ever get recovered??  Not even god or buddha can help you.

1.  The stimulation effect on boosting consumption is reduced when people tend to keep the money without spending it.

2.  The nature of the coupon encourages affulent population to donate it for the below average population, who need assistance most, and $3600 per person is not sufficient for them.

3.  A 2nd discount market will not affect the stimulation effect.  You sell the coupon at a discount and get the cash you want, but the ultimate purchaser of the coupon needs to spend on consumption any how. And by discounting, say from $100, to $90, to $80, say A, B, C each got $100 coupons

If they each consume, there results in $300 purchase in the economy.

If A sells to B for $90, B again to C for $80, B and C each spend their own $100

then A got $90 benefit

B got $(100-90)+$100

C got $(100-80)+$100  total: $320 instead of $300.

怎麼做都會有人罵吧

如果政府不掏錢出來又如何?

何不是會被罵

會拿去繳水電瓦斯費等等的大概屬於用盡辦法省錢的那類....吧!!

不然..

快過年了..除舊佈新..換個傢俱家電也不賴..買些食材加菜也OK..

會想辦法省錢的..不管用什麼方式..都會折現存下來..

沒差這些零頭的..反正都會花錢..限制消費類別還嫌麻煩..

介於兩者中間的..如果使用夠方便..就可以刺激購買慾望..

看了新聞報導..許多人想要購買非生活必需品(如3C產品)..包括我自己..

如果還要拿去買生活必需品..然後拿原本生活必需品預算買資訊產品..

跟直接拿消費券買資訊產品折抵現金..雖然實際消費總額一樣..心理層面卻有所不同..

我贊成發現金說

退稅....是不是有繳才有退

那窮人家都沒什麼繳了

要退什麼