網路城邦
上一篇 回創作列表 下一篇  字體:
Such an interview!
2006/02/10 11:01:27瀏覽371|回應9|推薦17

It has been a long time since I last interviewed a new grad, i.e. fresh graduted student. Lots of people like to ask technical questions to see how many things a candidate knows. I also like to see how many things the candidate knows, but more about himself, not technically. I believe that as long as a person is good enough, most of the things can be trained at the job. I like to hire those who know what they want, and know how to say it.

This interview earlier this week was a very interesting one. It was arranged by my co-worker. I didn't even know about it until last minute that this guy was considered a candidate for my group! Among all the 100 plus resumes I received, I have not set up any on-side interview yet. How could this guy be invited? so far, none of those 1/4 candidates my team's pre-screened passed. So, this one came as a surprise. I figured that he might used his network or connection to get the interview. To me, if the hiring manager does not arrange an interview, it usually does not send a good message to the hiring manager.

The objective line of the resume read as:Looking for a career in the area of VLSI design where my qualification and analytical ability can be used in developing a new technology through innovative research.

First guide line for the new grads: Do not send a identical/standard resume to every company! You need to show respect to the person/company you interview with, at least show them you know what this job is about!

First impression of mine was that, how many people are doing innovative research in the industry? I did not have a innovative project in my division at all. How comes this guy is looking for such job, as a fresh new grad? By the way, the only position opened in my division is for TME, Technical Marketing Engineer. There were a few more people interviewed this guy before me. So, his answer to my question: "Which job do you think fit with you the best?" His answer was Technical Marketing Engineer. Surprise, surprise! Some one in my group tipped him. The next question I asked was "Please define a TME position."

He told me a TME is a interface between blah, blah, blah, a standard anwser that my TME's would tell people. This actually killed half of his chance to work for me. I like people who are able to speak his own words, not to repeat other's words. I asked again. "Please define a TME in your own words." He was hung in front of the whiteboard.

Lesson #2: Be consistent with your resume. If you want a job that is innovative, research, don't tell me you are looking for a TME position. Please say you don't know if you don't know. Also, go to the basic if you try to answer. Technical Marketing Engineer, how hard is it to define? An engineer doing marketing job with technical aspect, something like that would be better than trying to tell me what my team tell you. I am the one define the job function, and I knew those descriptions were not even close to what my team are working on and what I was looking for. I like to have someone who could know better than me in defining the job in the future. Expect to see how I grilled this guy. Evil me!

Immediately, I started to feel guilty. How could I become a cold-blooded person without any mercy after all these years in the industry? So, the interview turned a little bit warmer after that, or at least I tried to. Technical questions were about to come, but I need a transition. "Please introduce yourself in two minutes." Now it was a standard question in interview, he must be prepared, right? Wrong again! "I am a digital designer, and am looking for a job in that area." As shocked as me, I have no way to get myself out from this interview. We are in analog-mixed-signal area, and this guy replied me the least interesting part of himself.

Lesson #3: When you introduce yourself, make sure you tell people about your background, like I graduated from XXX university with MSEE background, and interesting in XXXX area, and am looking a positin that would help me to establish my career ,etc.

Since he replied to me with that answer, I had to go with him. So, "Could you tell me what you can do in digital design? "I am a digital designer!" He gave me that answer again. What an easy way to do interview, one answer for all. This is like my Zen philosophy. All the questions comes to a single answer. The question raised in my mind, does he really knows anything about digital design? "What kind of digital circuits did you design?" I toned down quite a bit because I had zero interest on this guy, but I had to the good will to end it in a good way. "Just any kind of digital designs!" "Hum, this guy would never learn.Anyone knows how complicated digital circuit design is? It takes a lots of procedure to design from system level to implementation, to silicon. And he was telling me he could do any digital design??? "Ok, tell me how to design a digital TV." The question went out before I even realized. "So the electrical signal need to go through a electrical component then go through a optical component." After about two minutes, he drew two boxed on the board. "That's it?" I talked to myself in such disbelief. "There is no need to continue. Now, my good will showed up and try to help this guy do better in his next interview. God bless him if he get one.

"Could you tell me your best accomplishment in your life?" I asked politely. "My best accomplishment was getting into the college, which was the top college in India." and "I studied really hard, and got in with special honor."

Lesson #4: If your best honor was something happened seven years ago, you have wasted your life.

Come on! MIT does not buy you a job, NTU, or whatever education can not be your best accomplishment. We need someone who knows what to do and push for making progress. Innovative research? Be honest with you, not that many such jobs are available in the job market. Even R&D such does not exist anymore. It has to be either research or development. It is hard to find a job that allow you to research and develop in IC industry.

For anyone who might have interview opportunity, please be prepared! Don't get me wrong, I really respect everyone who works with me................... Just as much as he/she respects him/herself.

( 心情隨筆工作職場 )
回應 推薦文章 列印 加入我的文摘
上一篇 回創作列表 下一篇

引用
引用網址:https://classic-blog.udn.com/article/trackback.jsp?uid=scliao&aid=173307

 回應文章


等級:
留言加入好友
interview
2006/02/16 00:11
I've always been nervous when I face an interview.  I think there is one of good way ~  Practice over and over before you go~  Make yourself confident is important.  Interviews can be nice experiences!

■♀醫楊曉萍
等級:8
留言加入好友
My last experience
2006/02/11 18:28

This remind me of my last experience. We were looking forward to find a experienced "case manager". However, at least one third of the self introduction stared with 'I am willing to learn more in this field' ......



稻柏臨
等級:8
留言加入好友
Bad interview
2006/02/11 10:56

Thank you for all the feedback, and encouragements. 

This is probably the worst interview I ever had.  I have to admit that I was clueless when I interviewed this poor guy.  There were a few more questions that aimed for more directly to his technical areas, and I just skipped them.  Otherwise, the article would be too long and too technical.  Several of the questions I asked were open questions during this interview.  No matter what,  in real life, the way to answer the questions should follow the same philosophy:  

If you do not understand the question, ask them to repeat or re-phrase the question.  You can make up an answer that is worst then "I don't know how to answer this question."


jessamine
等級:7
留言加入好友
拍拍手
2006/02/10 16:48

說的真好.  實際. 實用 又實在.


小小豆
等級:7
留言加入好友
原來如此
2006/02/10 13:57

Technical Marketing Engineer

The reason why are you to values articulute of your team.

Am I right?

You're really a fine controller.whether your experience or hint,

It's all good for job hunter.


獨角獸
等級:8
留言加入好友
呵~呵!
2006/02/10 13:43

真巧,我今天才去面試的內!下周一要開始上班囉~~(不能再做夜貓族獨角獸了,唉!


孟宗
等級:6
留言加入好友
精彩極了
2006/02/10 13:10

最好看的地方是主試官的心情轉折

除了傳遞求職須知外,有專業有省思,更含哲理


V
等級:7
留言加入好友
thank ya!
2006/02/10 12:40

thank you for this article.

my sister's about to graduate from college...

this one will do her a lot of goodl!lllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll l



cease
等級:7
留言加入好友
這篇對想去面試的新畢業生可真有幫助
2006/02/10 11:12

主試官~

你還真是幫了很多人的忙,

貼了這麼好的一篇面試機宜呀~^^