網路城邦
上一篇 回創作列表 下一篇  字體:
我看2006奧斯卡最佳影片獎
2006/03/06 18:25:18瀏覽664|回應9|推薦18

奧斯卡只是影劇學院內五、六千人的民意調查. 奧斯卡是反映美國某一群人在乎的題材, 與他們肯定的演出, 作品. 奧斯卡是非常主觀的!我只想以我的一些心情來談一談, 該如何看待奧斯卡這麼一個獎項.  

For example,there is this debate that I have with myself today.
Should I write about my great half day trip with my family in
San Francisco, or comment on the true purpose of the World Classics
Baseball, or talk about Hollywood movie culture with the Academy
Awards? Actually, I wasn't thinking about writing today, but just that
I don't think I would sleep well if I don't.

The trip to San Francisco was my personal experience, which was the
most important thing in my life, and it was also something that I have
caught on the films, or more appropriate, the flash card. I can write in
next week without losing any major things. The WBC is the least
interesting topic in my mind, same as most of the American baseball
fans, at least before Koreans took on Japanese, and eventually took
the game from the arrogant Ichiro Susuki-led Japanese team. The
academy awards, seems so far away from me, but actually reminded
me many things, like how Ang Lee sticked with the philosophy he
believed when I heard his talk ten years ago, worked with what he
loves for all these years, and tonight, become the most famous
Chinese in the world, or at least in the global Chinese community.

Yes, there is this three-way perplexity just as it might be as
part of our daily lives. To think more about it, I learn an important
lesson, you should try to realize what you care the most. Think again,
what is important to you now, and what is the thing you should care
the most at this very moment? In my example, life with my family,
with my kids, it is an on-going thing. It lasts and it is going to be part
of my life, written down or not, plus there will be always be some
excitements everyday. WBC, it is just a baseball tournament, could be
a real classics, or could be a bust. I am not going to jump on any
quick judgement. Academy Awards, the Oscar, is actually what I would like to talk about the most, not every Academy Awards but this one.

Academy Awards is about movies. Just like movie, the awards are
very personal things. Annie Proulx's short story, versuses the
provocative, unflicnhing look of the 36 hours drama of the normal
people's life. "Brokeback Mountain" showed me two things, one is the
loves, especially between the homosexual cowboys, and the love of
the nature. "Crash" is actually a movie about the life that I am living in,
justwith more complexities, of the racial tolerance, and happened in
the city I lived for years when I first came to US.

Tina said to me that she felt Annie Proulx was right about not having
confidence on Ang about directing the movie because he was from
Taiwan, a metropolitan country. It is what I want bring up the most.
Is Taiwan really a metro-country? Is that why I couldn't fit in Taiwan?
I had that personal urge that nature was calling me every day while
I was fighting for the dream that our lives will be better if we kept
working hard? Ang Lee is different and is successful because he believes
in his dream. I am not sure whether he does believe in himself
to be where he is today. In one of the interview ETTV showed today,
Ang Lee was talking about Academy awards when he was in high
school. How long has he tried to live up that dream? Hope his father
were able to see him winning the best director today.

As to the best movie, I believe "Crash" win it with legit reasons. Movie,
is not just about story, is not about director. It is about actings, cast,
message, etc. Ang's movie might have lost because the "Gay"
image, or because of the "Cowboy" part of the movie. "Crash" is so
powerful, and so direct when it put all the elements together. I would
vote for "Crash" just by how Matt Dillon perform in that movie. A
house wife, a DA husband, a couple car hi-jackers, a few officers, and
the rest of the characters in the story, just give you the tension
about lives in the big city. In US, facing the crimes in the big city,
dealing the diversity of cultures or even in the same working
environment are big challenges. Hollywood, it is about making movies
that people can understand and would pay to watch. "Brokeback
Mountain"? Two of my five best white guy friends told me that they
would rather go to see the ballet. Can this movie win Academy Awards,
the symbol of American movie? I don't think so.

For those of you who is about to make your judgement, stop, and
think again. Things are not that straightforwards, but it is not that
complicate neither. Find out what you like, what you REALLY like.
Criticize as hard as you want, but, don't jump into any quick
judgement.

After I wrote this articel, I found out there is one article with great
detail about the movie "Crash". 比斷背山更可能奪獎的電影撞車(衝擊效應)

( 心情隨筆雜記 )
回應 推薦文章 列印 加入我的文摘
上一篇 回創作列表 下一篇

引用
引用網址:https://classic-blog.udn.com/article/trackback.jsp?uid=scliao&aid=196522

 回應文章

獨角獸
等級:8
留言加入好友
好片一定要去看
2006/03/10 22:32

"衝擊效應"這部片一出來我就去看了,真的讓我的心十分的衝擊與震憾!我想到了一句話:"牽一髮而動全身,牽一絲而動全網"~~每一個人不經意的一個小動作或一句話,就會造成相當震憾的結果,不管是好的結果或是壞的結果,我記得我一看完電影,整個胸口變得非常非常的悶,那種無法用言語形容的沉痛與省思,讓我感受相當強烈,這真的是一部好電影~~~~~推薦大家一定要去看!


稻柏臨
等級:8
留言加入好友
我希望的是...
2006/03/08 13:54

我希望的是 人能夠了解 自己內心深處真正要的是什麼!

拍片 如果只想得獎 那不拍也罷 拍片 是一種藝術 一種表達

每一個人想表達的 多少不同

看電影也是  每一個人 想要的 應該也是或多或少不同的

看電影是一種共鳴 這種類似的討論 應該著重在 我們愛斷背山 的哪一部分? 不喜歡得是哪一部分 而不全集中在它該不該得獎 李安的言論 因為他是斷背山的一份子 就像家人一樣 希望全家能共享榮譽  但是身為觀眾的我們 有選擇我們從心底喜歡的是什麼?

喜歡斷背山 是喜歡它的細膩  表達許多社會關係 喜歡它將自然如此的呈現在大家面前 且認同它的故事主軸 希望台灣的人喜歡斷背山 希望大家已經可以談同性戀而不臉紅 

台灣的人都喜歡斷背山是合理的 但不代表 "衝擊效應" 得獎是不恰當的


■♀醫楊曉萍
等級:8
留言加入好友
哈, 樓下的
2006/03/08 12:43
斷背, 斷袖, 斷臂.....

■♀醫楊曉萍
等級:8
留言加入好友
愛看奧斯卡
2006/03/08 12:42

Oscar is different from money making. 版主對於Osacr的期待或觀感, 倒是與敝人相當一致.

數年前寫了就是"愛看奧斯卡", 那時許多藝人直接槓上出兵伊拉克的布希, 便是想平反自小一貫被專業人事貶抑的演藝學會.

比起來, 威尼斯影展更政治囉, 專門鼓勵弱勢電影, 但是用心並不被質疑, 因為他不與利益直接相關

來自演藝強國的OSCAR, 對於整體影片品質的重視, 還是相當專業, 既然不諱言選擇的是"美國片", 就必須從美國觀點出發....從提名名單來看, 相當值得尊重



美安 meian
等級:7
留言加入好友
李安棒
2006/03/08 12:15

比較客觀來說:斷臂山的呼聲已最高

比較主觀來說:還是要保障<護>國片


稻柏臨
等級:8
留言加入好友
My personal observation
2006/03/08 08:21

Just try to give more complete story about the budgeting story.  I remember the budget for Brokeback Mountain was $14 million, for Crash, which was completely independent, the cost was only $7.5 millions, Goodnight and Good luck cost $6.5 millions.  Capote also cost about $7 millikon. Transamerican cost only $1 million. Only Spielberg spend $75 million for Munich, was exceptional. It is very unusally that the best picture nominees were dominated by independent or low-budget films. 

Big budget films are actually like Geisha, $85 million, King Kong $200 million.  Many actors and actresses are frustrated about how big company run the movie business.  This is a good trend for Hollywood since we might be able to see more quality films down the road. 

Oscar is different from money making.  Ask Ang Lee, and he can tell you whether they are making money or not with Brokeback Mountain.  Don't dream about asking Ang to save the Taiwanese movie business.  Being recognized and making money from movies are two different stories.


稻柏臨
等級:8
留言加入好友
最佳影片 為什麼不是「斷背山」
2006/03/08 08:05

好萊塢眾所周知,保羅赫吉斯為了拍「衝擊效應」,累出病來,電影拍到一半,心臟病發送醫急救,不過在他出院後幾個小時之內,立刻趕到洛杉磯交通繁忙的十字路口,拍攝片中撞車的重頭戲,很多人都覺得「衝擊效應」是保羅用命換來的。

去年克林伊斯威特執導「登峰造擊」,保羅正是編劇,該片贏得多項大獎,獨缺保羅獲獎,很多行家早就預測,奧斯卡今年一定會還他該得的獎。

奧斯卡前,當「斷背山」強打非奧斯卡投票主流的國際影展與美國各大影評人協會,「衝擊效應」卻鴨子划水,向真正有投票權的影藝學院諸公婆發動攻勢,據說送出超過三萬張DVD,有人一口氣收到五、六片,超過三千位非同志、傳統保守的投票者(奧斯卡今年投票者有五千七百九十八位),深深被感動。

「斷背山」描述六○年到八○年同志、婚姻、社會等問題,「衝擊效應」卻瞄準現代洛杉磯的種族衝突、階級鬥爭、社會問題,彷彿每天發生每個人身邊,與觀眾的距離更貼近。

開獎前夕,美國各大新聞網已開始分析「衝擊效應」將是斷背山的最大勁敵。

【2006-03-07/聯合報/A3版/奧斯卡李安之喜宴】


稻柏臨
等級:8
留言加入好友
UDN article about the same topic 最佳影片 為什麼不是「斷背山」
2006/03/08 08:04

觀察站

最佳影片 為什麼不是「斷背山」

「衝擊效應」/導演保羅人脈比李安更多更廣 鴨子划水 打動非同志、傳統保守的投票者


特派記者葛大維/洛杉磯五日電


「衝擊效應」擊敗「斷背山」獲得奧斯卡最佳影片,對李安和華人來說,肯定是衝擊,但在頒獎之前,其實早就有跡可循。

「斷背山」成本一千四百萬美元(折合新台幣四億四千八百萬元),「衝擊效應」比它更少,只有七百五十萬美元(折合新台幣二億四千萬元),而且只拍了三十四個工作天,是一部比「斷背山」更充滿刻苦耐勞精神的獨立製片。

「衝擊效應」導演保羅赫吉斯,雖然是第一次執導劇情長片,不過他在好萊塢經營二十多年,曾拍電視劇、當電影編劇,累積的人脈,絕對比李安更多更廣。

所以從保羅說要拍「衝擊效應」後,包括珊卓布拉克、麥特狄倫等大明星,主動願意降片酬演出,顯見保羅獲得同行的支持,後來在好萊塢以及奧斯卡投票勢力甚大的演員工會,均擊敗「斷背山」獲得最佳影片。


小斗
等級:7
留言加入好友
回应
2006/03/07 09:51

原本只想写几句回应,但却发觉有太多东西想说,所以写了这篇文。

https://city.udn.com/v1/blog/article/article.jsp?uid=4558665&f_ART_ID=197191

一篇比较啰嗦的感想。