最近臺灣修改教科書問題在媒體被炒得沸沸揚揚,在BBC中文版面上的討論感覺臺灣民衆正負評價一半一半.不知道樓主怎麽看這個問題.

對于去中國化我比較擔心,畢竟兩岸經濟上面的差距可以慢慢縮小,但是文化上肆意割裂對未來會有很大的後果.這次教科書的修改雖然感覺在兩岸論述上感覺更加切合實際,但是將所有"大陸"這些詞語通通改成中國却感覺很不可取. 中國跟臺灣一定要區別得那麽清么? 在誰也不知道歷史以後的軌迹前保持其中一定的模糊空間不是更好么? 其中是否會設及違憲問題?因爲畢竟現在中華民國憲法名義上還包括中國大陸. 當然我是基于大陸人士的觀點看問題,跟臺灣人想得肯定不一樣.

可能是家庭背景原因,我個人對中華民國這個名字的認可程度甚至比中華人民共和國還要高.因爲共和已經表明主權在民了,不用再加人民兩個字了. 感覺中華民國頌也更符合中國人的氣質, 而不象義勇軍進行曲那樣如此得具有鬥爭性. 但我得聲明一下,持我這一個想法的大陸人頂多1%,是個例.其實我想說的是,名字不是那麽重要,重要得是文化的中國這個概念.有時候,文化上的這個概念甚至比政治上的概念更加重要.

另外,文化的傳承能够割裂么??

想起89年64事件之後,當時民國政府的政策是所有大陸异見人士只要放弃中華人民共和國國籍就可以直接取得民國國籍.我看了很震撼,雖然我知道這其中政治因素起到很大作用.但我現在不禁反問,那時候民國政府都有那樣的胸襟,現在却拘泥于一個"臺灣國"概念不放,到底是倒退還是進步??

To:123酷媽,
1.China has avoided emphasizing communist. 
The status Quo is the best for both sides.
2. The Internet has made Mainland impossible to block the flow of world information. Hu had no choice but adopt a rather flexible policy toward Taiwan.
3.Hu plays U.S. cards to deal with TI. "There is no place for Taiwan Independence."

Unfortunately, that's true.

Well, I would say the chinese mainstream would definitely welcome "Wai Sheng Ren" if they have known the truth. Most of people in PRC have no idea of the history background and the current situation of "Wai Sheng Ren". They view "Taiwaner" as a whole, ignorating the inner differences of people groups.

However, if people have recognised the voting tricks of DPP, those tricks can not work every time. The point is that, how many local people of Taiwan would deny that obsolete views which DPP proclaims. They are good at voting, but not in administration.

Every time when I see words in forums in Taiwan like that,

"你們外省人爲什麽都不滾囬大陸去"

I also feel hurted. It's just ridiculous, as I know, the local people of Taiwan were also in mainland before, what the logics they follow!!! Futunately, most of local people in taiwan do not think in that way.

As for subject matter "外省人, we have come to an dead end and no way out.
Every time when it comes to election, DPP use it as sole weapon to beat KMT.
Not much people can do about it. The "外省人 works like magic toward those
KMT and considered that the party belonging to "外省人.I am living in CA. Either side of Chinese mainstream does not welcome me or
Islander of DPP as far as the politics is concerned. The good point with Taiwan
is that the government still tolerates this kind of opinion while Chinese side censor & filter the view not in their favor.

其實我26歲:)

我對臺灣的瞭解基本上基于各國媒體報紙,臺灣網絡加上我自己的主觀思考.所以我對于台獨基本教義派的心理背景不是很瞭解,而且我確實對于日本統治臺灣50年的歷史也不大瞭解.

因爲我在德國,德國對于民粹主義非常警惕.但是我發現基本上臺獨教義派都是用民粹主義來作爲武器,很多言論放到德國都是要坐牢的.如果套用他們的理論放在大陸比如:在中國的朝鮮族不愛中國因爲是從朝鮮過來的,真的會貽笑大方. 所以按照我的理解,我不怕台獨教義派整天聒噪,但真的擔心大陸臺灣缺少溝通彼此誤解一直加深造成更大的隔閡和大陸民主改革步伐太慢失去看起來越來越小的機遇.

我想如果大陸領導人真的基于臺灣民衆對于大陸極大的正面以及負面的情感來作决策的話真的會好很多.大陸對于臺灣瞭解得太少!

I agree that was a giant step for PROC.
Remember what Armstronge said when he landed to the moon?
" That was a small step for an astronaut, but a giant step for the mankind."

Mr. Mikky,

Yes. It's the shame that the chinese government does not allow the free access to the internet, although the most information is not blocked. I guess your blog is "filtered" since there are some sensitive words in your blog. However, I am now in Germany so I don't know exactly what happend.

To be honest, despite of that I am still optimistic of the loosing of internet monitoring in future. From the beginning of this year on accoring to new regulations the foreign media are allowed to have interview with any person in mainland without of the permittance of government. This would be a very a small, but may also be a "giant" step for media freedom.

 Thanks!

Mr. Fachuqu,

In my opinion, your point of view have been shared by most of bloggers, if not all.
However, I believe that Chinese bloggers are now blocked the entrance to the UDN
media. My friends in China, who had visited in the States, had tried to read my blog
and finally gave it up. I do not know when Chinese official is going to ease the media
monitoring. This may take a while. We need time to tell those people in power that
gradual easing the tight control of media and let people exchange view with each other
will do good in improving the understanding of two people with same cultures.